Thai Beverage - Phillip Securities 2020-05-18: Dry Spell In Watering Hole


Thai Beverage - Dry Spell In Watering Hole

  • Thai Beverage (SGX:Y92)'s 2Q20 revenue and earnings were below expectations. The 42% y-o-y collapse in Sabeco volumes hurt revenue and earnings. Excluding a one-off deferred tax hit of TBH1.08bn, PATMI would have risen 5% y-o-y.
  • Spirits division revenue in 2Q20 declined 3.9% y-o-y due to weaker volumes but PATMI rose 9.5% y-o-y due to lower marketing cost.
  • The ban in alcohol sales in Thailand from 10 April to 3 May, will temporarily suppress earnings in 3Q20.
  • We are lowering our target price to S$0.80 (previously S$0.95) as we cut earnings by 10%. Our BUY recommendation is unchanged.
  • The slump in volume for Sabeco was worse than expected. And the damage from regulatory changes will linger longer than the current containment measures due to the outbreak. Nevertheless, the spirits business account for close to 90% of group earnings and we expect demand to be more resilient.

The Positives

Margin stable for spirits business despite weaker volumes.

  • Operating profit for spirits business was flat y-o-y at TBH6.46bn despite the fall in revenue. The expansion in margins was due to a 10% y-o-y decline in distribution expenses to TBH1.69bn. Spirits PATMI was up 9.5% y-o-y to TBH5.35bn and now accounts for 88% of group earnings.

The Negatives

Sabeco will remain problematic for a few quarters.

  • Sabeco volumes have been punished by three key events: fake new, decree 100 and Covid-19 economic hit. Decree 100 in Vietnam introduced stiffer penalties for drunk driving, ban advertising of alcoholic beverages (between 6pm to 9pm). This has hit the on-trade (aka on-premises) (i.e. pubs, clubs) consumption of beer more than expected.


  • FY20e will be a weaker year for Thai Beverage. Softer economic condition and a collapse in on-trade consumption of alcohol will be the two largest negative impact on revenues. The only positive offset on earnings margins will be lower advertising and promotion activities.
  • The spirit business in Thailand will remain resilient despite the temporary ban enacted in April. Off-trade consumption (i.e. consumed at home) of spirits contributes approximately 80% of spirit sales and less impacted by Covid-19 social distancing measures. Demand is more linked to farm income levels and overall health of the economy.
  • More problematic for Thai Beverage will be Sabeco. The stiff penalties for drunk driving in Vietnam will hurt the business more permanently. Some on-trade volumes will be converted to off-trade but there may be some volume slippage is expected. Off-trade margins will be lower as on-trade bottle can be recyclable, thereby reducing cost. Although off-trade volume through modern retail can be higher, the higher percentage of off-trade sales will results in weaker margins.

Maintain BUY with PE-derived Target Price of S$0.82

Paul Chew Phillip Securities Research | 2020-05-18
SGX Stock Analyst Report BUY MAINTAIN BUY 0.80 DOWN 0.950