Sheng Siong Group - Phillip Securities 2019-07-31: Another Marvellous Year In Store Expansion


Sheng Siong Group - Another Marvellous Year In Store Expansion

  • SHENG SIONG GROUP LTD (SGX:OV8)'s 2Q19 revenue was above our expectations. PATMI was marginally below estimates due to higher operating cost from new stores and S$800k negative impact from the new lease accounting standard.
  • After opening three stores in May, Sheng Siong Group is tendering for another six new stores in 2H19.
  • The interim dividend was raised by 6% to 1.75 cents.
  • We modestly reduced our FY19e profit forecast due to the change in accounting method. Our recommendation is lowered from BUY to ACCUMULATE following the share price performance. Our target price of S$1.30 is unchanged.
  • Sheng Siong Group is still riding on the growth of its store expansion and market share gains.

The Positives

Sales growth was healthy.

  • 2Q19 sales growth of 11.8% y-o-y was above our modeled 7%. Growth was due to the expansion of 10 new stores last year.
  • Sheng Siong Group is taking market share as the supermarket industry contracted by 0.8% in 2QMay19.
  • Sheng Siong Group is growing more than 10x faster than the industry.

Bidding for at least six new stores.

  • Sheng Siong Group is tendering for six new HDB stores, with the results expected in August. Assuming a hit rate of 50%, three new stores could be opened in September. This will boost the total number of stores by 11%.
  • We believe there is further upside in new stores for Sheng Siong Group. It excludes four HDB stores available for online bidding and any tenders by private shop owners from supermarket tenants that are exiting.

Gross margins improved but could have been better.

  • The contribution of fresh product to group sales continue to rise and pull up margins. Margins could have been better. Raw material costs has been higher than anticipated due to volatile weather and swine flu. It was highlighted that in a weak economy, households tend to cook more at home.

The Negatives

Operating cost high due to new stores.

  • As a percentage of sales, administrative expenses rose to 17.9% of sales. The rise was due to additional headcount for the new stores. The run-rate when stores are mature is around 16.5% of sales (FY14-17).

Same-store sales improved but remained soft.

  • 2Q19 same-store sales improved from last quarter but remain sluggish. In 1H19, Sheng Siong Group same-store sales declined 0.6% y-o-y, this is better than the 1.1% decline for supermarket sales located in malls.


  • The outlook is positive for Sheng Siong Group. We see multiple growth drivers over the next two years. Growth drivers include market share gains, store expansions, improved sales or productivity per sft and operating leverage as sales improve.

Downgrade to ACCUMULATE with unchanged Target Price of S$1.30.

  • Our Target Price is based on an estimated multiple of 25x PE F1Y9e. The downgrade is due to the recent rally in Sheng Siong Group's share price.
  • We view Sheng Siong Group as enjoying stable growth and offers attractive metrics from its 3.2% dividend yield, 25% ROE and S$87mn net cash balance sheet.

Paul Chew Phillip Securities Research | https://www.stocksbnb.com/ 2019-07-31
SGX Stock Analyst Report ACCUMULATE DOWNGRADE BUY 1.300 SAME 1.300