800 Super Holdings Ltd - Phillip Securities 2018-02-12: Lower PATMI, But Within Expectation

800 Super Holdings Ltd - Phillip Securities 2018-02-12: Lower PATMI, But Within Expectation 800 SUPER HOLDINGS LIMITED 5TG.SI

800 Super Holdings Ltd - Lower PATMI, But Within Expectation

  • 800 Super Holdings Ltd's 2Q FY18 revenue 5.4% lower than expected, PATMI in line with our estimate.
  • 1H FY18 revenue and PATMI met 48% and 46% respectively, of our full year estimate.
  • Negative surprise of absence of interim dividend (1H17: 1 cent).
  • Maintain ACCUMULATE; lower target price of $1.35 on cost pressures.

The Positives

➕ 12.7% y-o-y lower staff cost cushioned some impact of 8.3% y-o-y lower revenue. 

  • Staff cost is the largest cost component (54% of opex). Staff expense was lower, in line with completed contracts. But it was higher labour productivity as a result of continued efforts to optimise manpower and equipment deployment which drove cost down.

➕ Projects on-track and turning operational. 

  • The waste to energy (WTE) plant was completed in December 2017, and is expected to be operational in 1Q CY2018. The sludge treatment facility is on-track for completion in 2Q CY2018. (No change in schedule since the previous quarter’s results.)

The Negatives

➖ Revenue was lower than expected. 

  • We were expecting y-o-y lower revenue of ~3% and the actual 8.3% y-o-y lower revenue was worse than expected. 
  • We think that it is a reflection of the competitive nature of the contract cleaning business segment. Despite the weaker revenue, PATMI was within our expectation of $2.44m.

➖ Cost pressure weighing against margin. 

  • 5.0% decline in opex was less than the 8.3% decline in revenue. Depreciation expense was 13.6% y-o-y higher, in relation to new PPE for the WTE plant. 
  • Other expenses was 15.2% higher, mainly attributable to the acquisition of Iwash Laundry (Senoko) Pte Ltd.

➖ Negative surprise of absence of interim dividend. 

  • While it is a negative surprise, we find that there is good reason for it. We see that 1H18 free cash flow is negative, due to the construction of the WTE plant and sludge treatment facility. These two projects are expected to drive earnings and cash flow positively, after they are completed. 
  • Moreover, we believe there is a need to conserve cash, to fulfil the capex requirements of the public waste collection contract for the PasirRis-Bedok sector.


  • The outlook is stable to positive. Despite the y-o-y lower PATMI, it was not a negative surprise and it was within our expectation. 
  • In our recent reports, we had been stating our expectation of near-term PATMI weakness. This is on the basis of new initiatives coming on line, which will have the effect of higher depreciation expense with low revenue recognition during the ramp-up phase.

Maintain Accumulate; lower target price of $1.35 (previously $1.40) 

  • Due to the absence of an interim dividend, we have lowered our FY18e and FY19e full year dividend assumption to 3.0 cents; keeping final dividend assumption of 3.0 cents same as FY17. 
  • We have also made changes to our cost assumptions, resulting in our FY18e/FY19e PATMI estimates being 9%/9% lower than previous. 
  • We still like the stock for its future earnings growth arising from the new projects that will contribute positively. Our target price gives an implied FY18e forward P/E multiple of 17.8 times.

Richard Leow CFA Phillip Securities | https://www.stocksbnb.com/ 2018-02-12
Phillip Securities SGX Stock Analyst Report ACCUMULATE Maintain ACCUMULATE 1.35 Down 1.400