EZION HOLDINGS LIMITED 5ME.SI
A Tough Year So Far
- Ezion’s 2Q15 PATMI of USD29m missed estimates (a key reason being a cost overrun in Australia), but we highlight its strong operational cash flow (+88% YoY).
- Maintain BUY, with a lower SGD1.60 TP (121% upside, from SGD2.10) based on a 9x blended FY15F/16F P/E.
- A fourth contract expiring this year was renewed at the same rate, for 5+2 years, indicating strong liftboat demand.
- Our TP implies a 7x FY16F P/E and 1.3x P/BV.
Operational challenges in opening up new market in Australia.
- The Nora Sunrise (Unit #24) was the first liftboat ever introduced to Australia. Although it suffered a cost overrun due to local issues, which led to the need for additional repair expenses, it also succeeded in drawing interest – even from non-oil companies. We estimate the total excess costs at USD7m in 2Q15, part of which will spill into 3Q15.
Six units under repairs, upgrades, and dry dock inspection (RUDDI) will return to service by 4Q15.
- Management expects all six units to resume their charters by Sep-Dec 2015 (see Figure 2). The switch from pure costs to earnings contributions should have a positive operational leverage effect on Ezion’s earnings from 4Q15 onwards.
- On top of that, six new-build units will be delivered in 2H15 to bring its end-FY15 fleet size to 31 vessels, before growing to 37 vessels at end-FY16.
Short-term pain for long-term gain.
- In response to customer requests for higher-specification units or additional capex on current units, it is employing a strategy made possible by economies of scale – swapping units between customers to meet such requests, thereby lowering its overall incremental capex requirements. Seven units are affected, which may lead to utilisation gaps in 2Q15-3Q15.
- The upside is revenue visibility – two such contracts are for five years with two more optional years – which points to strong and continuous demand for liftboats.
Unwarranted discount.
- We switch to highly-conservative assumptions, pushing units under RUDDI out to 1Q16 deployment, and further taking a 10% cut on revenues for FY16F/FY17F in case of further issues.
- We cut our FY15F/FY16F earnings by 34/21%. Even so, we project it to deliver c.13-19% ROEs in FY15-17, and believe the 30-40% discount to BV is unwarranted. It is trading at 3x FY16F P/E and 2.5x operating cashflow.
- Key risks are execution problems and further delivery delays.
Lee Yue Jer CFA | http://www.rhbgroub.com/ RHB Securities 2015-08-17
1.60
Down
2.10